takudzwa ngwenya usa eagles americas rugby news

Amateur vs Pro – The Outside Backs

At last we come to the end of our comparison of Americas depth in terms of professionalism. We’ve looked at the forwards (front row / second row / back row), the halfbacks, and the midfield. Today it’s the speedsters who take centre stage – the outside backs. The South Americans have traditionally used smaller backs out wide who usually feature an array of footballing skills and stepping ability. In the North it’s been about finding the best athletes – strong, fast, and sturdy in composition.

Several of the players below are versatile and can play all across the back three, and some the midfield as well. While efforts have been made to put them a their most common position, the distinctions between right and left wing, for example, should be taken loosely.

Disclaimer:

These are not official depth charts, but attempt to replicate recent selection history as closely as possible. In virtually every case, an absent player who might currently be more appropriate shares the same status – pro or amateur – as the player included. Players included are those considered for the World Cup. In some cases those players have since retired from international rugby. Players are listed by their most recent club affiliation.

It’s important to note that some ‘amateur’ players in the Americas are not entirely unpaid. Some players receive a monthly stipend to supplement their income, particularly those on the World Sevens Series. A significant portion of those retain full-time jobs outside of their rugby commitment. While these players might not be truly ‘amateur’ in the strictest sense, for the purpose of this exercise those who are not full-time employees of a professional fifteen-a-side club or franchise will be considered so.

 

LEFT WING

The injury to Manuel Montero prior to the World Cup looked like a terrible blow to the Pumas, but luckily they have capable replacements, though none of his physical dimensions. Juan Imhoff’s decision to remain in France could well cost him a spot in the team, which highlights a new selection policy that seems unnecessarily rigid if that is indeed the case. Promising 20-year-old Emiliano Boffelli has played everywhere from flyhalf to fullback, and Tomás Carrió is just as likely to be at fullback as on either wing.

Canada have had professionals on the wing for years, and in DTH van der Merwe and Taylor Paris they have two players who stand out among their peers at club level. Beyond those two are several younger players, many of whom have also featured on the Sevens Series.

Los Teros have been using utility back Rodrigo Silva on the wing, despite his preference to play flyhalf. Francisco Bulanti was the oldest player on the World Cup roster and will almost certainly give way to younger players for future internationals.

The Eagles have been indecisive about their no11 jersey since Luke Hume (ex-Narbonne) fell out of contention with a badly broken ankle.  Chris Wyles and Blaine Scully have moved back and forth between wing and fullback, while Brett Thompson is also in the mix after failing to see game time at Edinburgh. Tim Maupin is playing in Dublin but didn’t really challenge for a World Cup spot.

ARG    
Juan Imhoff Racing 92 (FRA) PRO
Manuel Montero Jaguares (ARG) PRO
Emiliano Boffelli Jaguares (ARG) PRO
Tomás Carrió Duendes (ARG) AMATEUR
CAN    
DTH van der Merwe Scarlets (WAL) PRO
Taylor Paris Agen (FRA) PRO
Justin Douglas Abbotsford (CAN) AMATEUR
Jake Webster Lindsay (CAN) AMATEUR
URU    
Rodrigo Silva Carrasco Polo (URU) AMATEUR
Francisco Bulanti Trébol Paysandú (URU) AMATEUR
Federico Favaro Old Christians (URU) AMATEUR
Santiago Carrasco Ceibos (URU) AMATEUR
USA    
Blaine Scully Cardiff Blues (WAL) PRO
Brett Thompson Tempe (USA) AMATEUR
Tim Maupin Trinity College (IRE) AMATEUR
Lemoto Filikitonga Metropolis (USA) AMATEUR

 

RIGHT WING

Santiago Cordero was one of Argentina’s stars of the World Cup as he moved up from his usual fullback position to fill in for Montero, pushing Imhoff to the left wing. Ramiro Moyano is another flyer whose first choice is fullback, while Matías Orlando prefers centre but is often bumped to the wing. Gonzo Camacho finally returned to fitness this year but looks to be at the end of his test career, choosing instead to stay in England with Leicester.

Canada features the excellent Jeff Hassler on the right wing, with versatile Phil Mackenzie equally capable of playing in the midfield. Sean Duke has been a fixture in the sevens program for years, and Jordan Wilson-Ross has had limited opportunities at test level, zero at his preferred spot of outside centre.

Leandro Leivas is Uruguay’s most powerful attacking winger but saw his right wing spot go to utility back Santiago Gibernau in the World Cup. Younger brother Gastón is highly thought of but none have any professional experience.

Taku Ngwenya remains a lethal finisher at the age of 30, though his commitment to the Eagles jersey has been questioned at times. Zack Test has barely played any XVs in recent years, instead focusing almost entirely on 7s. Tim Stanfill is another with top class speed but has only recently been integrated into national sides at the relatively geriatric age of 26.

ARG    
Santiago Cordero Jaguares (ARG) PRO
Gonzalo Camacho Leicester Tigers (ENG) PRO
Ramiro Moyano Jaguares (ARG) PRO
Matías Orlando Jaguares (ARG) PRO
CAN    
Jeff Hassler Ospreys (WAL) PRO
Phil Mackenzie Sale Sharks (ENG) PRO
Sean Duke UVic Vikes (CAN) AMATEUR
Jordan Wilson-Ross James Bay (CAN) AMATEUR
URU    
Santiago Gibernau Carrasco Polo (URU) AMATEUR
Leandro Leivas Old Christians (URU) AMATEUR
Gastón Gibernau Old Boys (URU) AMATEUR
Juan Andrés Pena Seminario (URU) AMATEUR
USA    
Takudzwa Ngwenya Biarritz (FRA) PRO
Zack Test Eagles 7s (USA) AMATEUR
Tim Stanfill Seattle Saracens (USA) AMATEUR
Ben Leatigaga OMBAC (USA) AMATEUR

 

FULLBACK

The move to midfield of Juan Martín Hernández opened the door for Joaquín Tuculet to step up, and he has responded with some eye catching displays. Lucas González Amorosino played alongside Tuculet at Cardiff Blues last season, but has now joined Munster until January, when he is expected to return to Argentina to play for the Super Rugby franchise. Quality goal kicker Martín Bustos Moyano appears to be the forgotten man despite good form in France, while Román Miralles has been a mainstay in the ‘A’ side for many years.

Speaking of mainstays, the days of consummate professional James Pritchard in a Canadian jersey have finally come to an end. Matt Evans is the new fullback, with utility back Harry Jones his backup during the World Cup. Andrew Coe is the heir apparent, only 19 but very highly rated. His arrival in a national jersey appears to be very much a question of ‘when’, not ‘if’.

Los Teros have a new exile at fullback with Gastón Mieres currently on trial with semi-pro outfit Coventry. Next in line Jerónimo Etcheverry played for Valpolicella in Italy for three seasons, but has since returned to Uruguay. Matías Plá is their next hopeful after graduating from the u20 team.

Beyond Chris Wyles and Blaine Scully there aren’t many options at the moment for the Eagles. Troy Hall is a New Zealander who was dragged out of retirement by Mike Tolkin, while Zach Pangelinan is a flyhalf forced to play in the outside backs to get a sniff with the national selectors. Joe Cowley looked promising but has been persona non grata since early 2014.

ARG    
Joaquín Tuculet Jaguares (ARG) PRO
Lucas González Amorosino Munster (IRE) PRO
Román Miralles Duendes (ARG) AMATEUR
Martín Bustos Moyano Bayonne (FRA) PRO
CAN    
Matt Evans Cornish Pirates (ENG) PRO
Harry Jones Capilano (CAN) AMATEUR
James Pritchard Bedford Blues (ENG) PRO
Andrew Coe UBC Thunderbirds (CAN) AMATEUR
URU    
Gastón Mieres Coventry (ENG) PRO
Jerónimo Etcheverry Carrasco Polo (URU) AMATEUR
Matías Plá Seminario (URU) AMATEUR
Tomas Etcheverry Carrasco Polo (URU) AMATEUR
USA    
Chris Wyles Saracens (ENG) PRO
Troy Hall NYAC (USA) AMATEUR
Zach Pangelinan OMBAC (USA) AMATEUR
Joe Cowley Life University (USA) AMATEUR

 

OUTSIDE BACKS SUMMARY

Argentina have slightly less depth out wide, though they do have several quality professionals capable of covering multiple positions. Canada have good starters but largely unproven alternatives outside the senior squad. Uruguay have a handful of passable domestic talent and one player overseas. USA have three top drawer pros and some 7s players moonlighting as XVs wingers.

About Americas Rugby News

Formally created in June 2015, this website's goal is to increase media exposure of the Tier 2 rugby nations, and create a hub with a focus on the stories of rugby in the Americas - North, Central and South.

Check Also

Powerful Spain roster to face Teros and Eagles

Pablo Bouza has named a 42-man extended Spain roster for their upcoming test series against …